November 14, 2026
It was Manila in 1949. Manila was still recovering from the war. A rundown theater had been repurposed into a bar by Lillas Pastia (Noel Rayos). There was a stand there with an old movie poster was on it -- "The Loves of Carmen" -- showing star Rita Hayworth wearing a bright scarlet dress as she danced the flamenco. One day, a pretty woman came into the bar to seek shelter, and, upon seeing the poster, introduced herself as Karmen (Roxy Aldiosa).
A police officer named Jose (Bryan Homecillo) fell head over heels for Karmen at first sight, even if he is engaged to another woman Micaela (Angeli Benipayo). When she sang her first aria "Habanera," Jose was hopeless hooked and obsessed. However, when she met the charming Camillo (Ivan Nery) singing his "The Toreador Song," Karmen would seduce him. Later, Jose would also find out that Karmen had a first husband Garcia (Tarek El Tayech).
I knew of "Carmen," the classic 1875 opera written by French composer Georges Bizet, with libretto written by Henri Meilhac and Ludovic Halévy, based on the novella of the same title by Prosper Mérimée. As I am not exactly a fan of opera, I was only familiar with a couple of popular arias from it, which I identified above, but I did not know the story at all. I thought this was my chance to finally see this opera staged.
First, the positives. This whole show was in the Filipino language -- not only the spoken lines, but even the arias! It was translated and adapted by musical director Farley Asuncion from the abridged version of the original four-act opera, as adapted by British director Peter Brook. Brook cut the story and the songs down to its psychological basics only, putting it right down the alley of our local director Jaime del Mundo. This resulted in a trim run time of only 1 hour and a half with no intermission.
As the liberated temptress Karmen, Roxy Aldiosa gets to sing the fiery "Habanera" and the sultry "Seguidilla."Angeli Benipayo (also assistant director and co-translator) was poignant in her featured solo aria "Je dis que rien ne m'épouvante" (also called "Micaëla's Aria"). It was great to hear "The Toreador Song" being sung with swagger by Ivan Nery in its proper context in the story. I had seen Nery twice before as Ibarra in the opera version of "Noli Me Tangere," but that was more than 10 years ago.
This is the first time I have seen Bryan Homecillo, so I am not sure he is a bonafide opera singer. During this show that I caught, there were times when Homecillo was singing Jose's arias in a more pop manner, going into falsettos for his higher notes. However, his stage presence was strong, able to he draw attention to his character whenever he was on. Veteran stage actors Rayos, Sy and El Tayech played smaller roles who do not get to sing, but they still made their characters matter despite their relatively minimal stage time.
Keeping it honest, I can't really say that I liked this show completely, not exactly my cup of tea. I was disturbed with how unpleasantly the story turned out, with unlikable characters and needless violence. (That said, I did enjoy those exhilarating knife fights!) This is not to put down the cast and crew of this show, but likely this is just about my unfamiliarity with the material and genre. While I was writing this, I already read many raves about this show, so clearly I am in the minority. I still have so much to learn about the art of opera.
*********
KARMEN 1947 runs on November 13–15 & 20–22, 2026 at the the Doreen Black Box Theater, Areté, in the Ateneo de Manila University campus. Regular tickets cost P2000 each, free seating.
📅


























